The Daily WTF: “Job Interview 2.0″

If you don’t know The Daily WTF, you should…most of the content is programmer related (and usually goes over my head) but some of the content is quite interesting.

Take for example, the two blog posts below…they deal with Interviewing candidates. If you are a regular reader of my blog you’ll know I’ve blogged about Interviewing (here and here for example) and that I think that an organization should try their darnedest to hire the best people that they can.

The two posts below are meant to be funny but they also provide a bit of insight into the world of interviewing.

Design me a House (by David J)

In “Design me a House“, the author describes an interview that he knew fairly early on in the interview process that he wasn’t a good fit for but couldn’t quite get the interviewer to stop the interview. The interviewer jumped into a ‘Job Interview 2.0’ interview style and asked the following question:

“Design me a house,” the interviewer cheerfully demanded.

“Ugh,” I groaned, “what do you want your house to look like?”

“But aren’t you going to ask how many floors it should have,” he glibly responded.

“Fine. How many floors do you want?”

“Two!,” he shouted, “no, three! I mean, one! Err… no, I want six, maybe sev–“

The interviewee played along until he could take it no more and said:

“Look,” I interrupted, “I don’t mean to be rude, but you haven’t asked a single question about programming.”

The interviewer scoffed, “you’ve got a lot to learn about developing good software if you don’t see the relevance here.”

Thankfully, the interview ended shortly thereafter. And while they never did extend me an offer, they did end up going out of business later that year. Apparently, they had issues delivering software to their clients.

Job Interview 2.0: Now With Riddles!

In this blog post, the author approaches the ‘new’ ideas of job interview questions that have nothing to do with the job but try to pull out some ideas about the creativity, critical thinking abilities and other skills of the candidate. However, some of these questions can be very confusing and downright asinine.Take the example below that a reader of The Daily WTF sent in:

During a screening interview, I was asked how I would design a bike fit for someone visually impaired. I responded something to the effect of, “What, like, for blind people?”, and she answered yes.

I thought for a moment and then I responded, “Well.. a blind person riding a bike doesn’t sound like a very safe idea, so I would make the bike stationary, maybe with a fan blowing in the person’s face. He probably wouldn’t even know the difference.”

She was speechless.

The author goes on to say the following:

Now, granted, he will not get the job. Despite the complete absurdity of the design request, and the complete practicality of his answer, the job will go to a candidate who manages to answer the question by designing an extremely overcomplicated solution for a completely non-existent problem. And that candidate will be the same person who designs their software.

Analysis

Consider these questions (also from Job Interview 2.0: Now With Riddles!)

  1. How would you determine the weight of a Boeing 747?
  2. Given an opaque box with three light bulbs inside and three switches outside, how would you determine which switch corresponded to which bulb if the box could be opened only once and only after all the switches were permanently set?
  3. You are at a ravine with three others and need to cross a rickety bridge. You can cross it in one minute, the three others can cross it in two, five, and ten, respectively. A flashlight (your group has only one) is always required to cross, and only two people can cross at a time. How do you cross as quickly as possible?

Do questions like this really help you to determine who the person is and what they are capable of? Sure they may might help determine the creativity and critical thinking capabilities but these days I’d gamble that most of these questions are out on the net somewhere (e.g., google “how would you determine the weight of a boeing 747“) so you may have lost that ability as well.

Do you really want to ask your candidates silly questions like this or would you rather get to know the candidate on a more personal level? How about taking the candidate out for a coffee and spending some quality time interacting and getting to know them? That’s my approach at least.

When I’ve been asked these questions in the past my ‘BS’ alert starts to go off in my head and I start looking for the exit. Next time I’ll have to submit the interview The Daily WTF 🙂

6
Leave a Reply

avatar
6 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
arturo luengasBusiness StationaryNetwork MarketingSteve WileyThe “Design me a house” interview question | Aligning Technology, Strategy, People & Projects Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Steve Wiley
Guest

Reminds me of an interview I had years ago. The one thing I remember was the interviewer said something to the effect of “We don’t write fancy applications here; everything we do is basically quick and dirty”. That was all I needed to know and I ended the interview.

trackback

[…] a previous post titled “The Daily WTF: “Job Interview 2.0?“, I talked about an interviewee’s response to an interviewer asking him to […]

trackback

[…] interesting anecdotal evidence about the negative effects of these quirky tactics in this blog post here. There are some comments from job seekers about how questions like “How would you design a […]

Network Marketing
Guest

I really enjoyed your post. I will have to come back again to read some more of them.

Network Marketing's Recent post…null

Business Stationary
Guest

I hear you on the interviewing BS

I had an interview when I was younger, and was told to relax because they wanted to get to know me.

Then 1 person began to run off some questions, while the other 2 took notes. Yes, 3 people interviewing me for a $12/hr position. If I am not mistaken the president does not have to face that much scrutiny.

trackback

RT @ForoFeminista: #feminismo Re: Un símbolo del feminismo pide que dejen de humillar a los hombres: Claro que es… http://bit.ly/gYoCG

If you'd like to receive updates when new posts are published, signup for my mailing list. I won't sell or share your email.